accounting for commitment fees by borrower

As discussed in ASC 835-30-45-1A, debt issuance . typical derivative loan commitment, the borrower can choose to: 2 In accordance with the Background Information and Basis for Conclusions in Statement of Financial Accounting Standards No. The percentage fee generally varies between 0.25% and 1%. In applying the effective interest method under IFRS 9, the lender identifies fees that are an integral part of the effective interest rate of a financial instrument, and these are treated as an adjustment to the effective interest rate (IFRS 9, paragraph B5.4.1). Fees that are NOT considered an integral part of the effective interest rate are then accounted for under IFRS 15 (refer Step Two below). All Rights Reserved. Please see www.pwc.com/structure for further details. Mon - Fri: 7:30 - 4:30. IAS 23 states, "Borrowing costs are interest and other costs that an entity incurs in connection with the borrowing of funds.". Borrowing costs help companies finance asset construction, acquisition, or production. IFRS 9, paragraph B5.4.3. After the loan is paid off the net effect of these transactions on the accounting equation will be as follows: The assets of the company decreased by $ 167,500. (All You Need to Know), What is the Rule 407 letter? The commitment fee shall be calculated quarterly in arrears, and if there is any change in the Applicable Rate during any quarter, the actual daily amount shall be computed and multiplied by the Applicable Rate separately for each period during such quarter that such Applicable Rate was in effect. '{,zx7(AcRV/a6P%y2j,0nlL|B^S*_-MPcXh1Bv=V3BJl|8pZL@4uy9Sd4< that were necessary costs in order to obtain a loan. According to International Accounting Standard # 18 (illustrative example related to rendering of services para 14) which states: "Fees received by the entity relating to the creation or acquisition of a financial asset, such fees may include compensation for activities such as evaluating the borrower's financial condition, evaluating and . The company completes all the activities necessary to prepare the qualifying asset for its intended use or sale. Definition, Explanation, Example, and More, What is a Secured Loan? When companies borrow finance from other parties, they also bear some costs. Companies use assets for various purposes, primarily including the generation of revenues. What are advisory firms, and how do they earn money? Illustration: A Borrower enters into a new term note with its bank. b. The tax treatment of those expenses may vary. It also includes our accounting guidance that applies as a company responds to the five debt accounting questions described above. endstream endobj 53 0 obj <> endobj 54 0 obj <> endobj 55 0 obj <>/Rotate 0/Type/Page>> endobj 56 0 obj <>stream Usually, companies have an intended use or sale for those assets. The agreement requires a loan origination fee of $15,000, which is paid by the Borrower to the Lender at the date of the loans closing. More about the commitment fee will be discussed below. F. August 14, 2019 at 5:07 pm . The $15,000 is debited under the header "Loans". Qualifying assets include resources that necessarily take a substantial period to get ready. What are the journalRead more . Accrued commitment fees shall be payable in arrears on the last day of March, June, September and December of each year and on the Termination Date, commencing on the first such date to occur after the date hereof. If the borrower cannot re . 96-11), would IFRS 9, paragraph B5.4.2(a), Monthly fee charged to the customer for administration of the loan, Fee paid to mortgage broker for arranging the loan that is recharged to the customer, Referral fee in respect of a loan that is recharged to the customer, Fee for collecting interest and principal repayments from the borrower and passing it on to fund providers, Fee paid to lender in return for the lender committing to lend to borrower a certain amount, and it is probable that the borrower will draw down the amount, IFRS 9 Amount deferred until loan is drawn down and the fee is included in the EIR, Fee paid to lender in return for the lender committing to lend to borrower a certain amount, and it is unlikely that the borrower will draw down the amount, IFRS 15, recognise the commitment fee as revenue over the period of the commitment, Commitment fees only probable that half of the amount is to be drawn down, Fee paid to the lender in return for the lender committing to lend to the borrower a certain amount, and it is only probable that 50% of the facility would be used. Revolving Credit Commitment Fee Prior to the Interest Rate Election Date (if any), Borrower shall pay to the Administrative Agent for the ratable account of the Lenders in accordance with their Revolver Percentages a commitment fee on the average daily Unused Revolving Credit Commitments at a rate per annum equal to (x) 0.20% if the average daily Unused Revolving Credit Commitments are less than 50% of the Revolving Credit Commitments then in effect and (y) 0.25% if the average daily Unused Revolving Credit Commitments are greater than or equal to 50% of the Revolving Credit Commitments then in effect (computed on the basis of a year of 360 days and the actual number of days elapsed) and determined based on the average daily Unused Revolving Credit Commitments during such previous quarter. the commitment fee as a cost of acquiring the loan that is to be deducted ratably over the term of the loan. The company purchased the site for $21 million. The fee may also be associated with a commitment to charge a contracted interest rate, rather than the (presumably higher) market interest rate at the time the loan is actually used. Therefore, this definition meets the explanation for those costs listed above. Master accounting topics that pose a particular challenge to finance professionals. Commitment fees to originate a loan where it is unlikely that the specific lending arrangement will be entered into. Are you still working? Similarly, it may involve finance charges on finance leases. Instead, companies make these costs a part of the assets recognition cost. The overarching accounting theory when accounting for these debt issuance costs is the utilization of the matching principle. USA June 29 2018. If the commitment is subsequently exercised during the commitment period, the remaining unamortized commitment fee at the time of exercise shall be recognized over the life of the loan as an adjustment of yield. The tax treatment of these fees is not the same as the . Frequently, commitment fee and interest are often confused with another. In both cases, the IRS concluded that the commitment fees were deductible under Sec. A commitment fee is the amount charged by a lender to keep a specific loan amount available to a borrower. Banks often charge a commitment fee to borrowers for reserving the unused portion of the line of credit. Note that legal expenses incurred by lender will be accounted for as an expense and the recharge from the customer is accounted for as revenue. Save & file. To determine whether it is probable that not all principal and/or interest will be collected and an allowance for loan losses should be recorded, the Bank should consider all relevant factors, including (1) the occurrence of significant changes in the borrower's financial position that indicate that the borrower may not be able to repay the obligation, in whole or . However, these costs apply to the context of the assets they finance. Please seewww.pwc.com/structurefor further details. Feature, Process, Types, Advantages, and Limitations. However, these costs must relate to the assets acquisition, construction or production. An Industry Overview, 100+ Excel Financial Modeling Shortcuts You Need to Know, The Ultimate Guide to Financial Modeling Best Practices and Conventions, Essential Reading for your Investment Banking Interview, The Impact of Tax Reform on Financial Modeling, Fixed Income Markets Certification (FIMC), The Investment Banking Interview Guide ("The Red Book"), Revolvercommitment fees are still treated as a capital asset. Company name must be at least two characters long. O~t7KZclv In exchange, the lender provides the assurance that it will provide the agreed loan . What is the offset for the debt discount? The Borrower also incurs legal costs of $5,000. The fee also secures a lenders promise to provide the credit line on the agreed terms at specific dates, regardless of the conditions of the financial markets. #5. There are various types of potential costs that relate to financing arrangements, some of which are: The loan fees are amortized through Interest expense in a Companys income statement over the period of the related debt agreement. 71 0 obj <>/Encrypt 53 0 R/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<02266ACF7EEFADEC7704F55FDE89365B>]/Index[52 39]/Info 51 0 R/Length 101/Prev 139500/Root 54 0 R/Size 91/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream Under IAS 23, these include the following. They will charge 9 % interest. Once companies satisfy those criteria, they can use the following journal entries for borrowing costs.DateParticularsDrCrAsset (Inventory, fixed assets, etc. The term. However, companies cannot capitalize on all borrowing costs when they occur. Effective December 15, 2015, an asset will no longer be created and the financing fee will be deducted from the debt liability directly as a contra-liability: To simplify presentation of debt issuance costs, the amendments in this Update require that debt issuance costs related to a recognized debt liability be presented in the balance sheet as a direct deduction from the carrying amount of that debt liability, consistent with debt discounts. IFRS 9) specify how to separate and/or initially measure one or more parts of the loan contract, then the lender first applies the separation and/or measurement requirements in those other Standards. My question is this: What would be the accounting treatment in the borrower's books for that example? The fee compensates the lender for the risks associated with an open credit line despite uncertain future market conditions and the lenders current inability to charge interest on the principal. The primary definition for borrowing costs comes from IAS Borrowing Costs. Credit Cash 10.3M . However, the underlying resource must meet the qualifying asset definition set by the standard. Most comprehensive library of legal defined terms on your mobile device, All contents of the lawinsider.com excluding publicly sourced documents are Copyright 2013-, Commitment Commission Fees Reductions of Commitment, Interest Rates and Letter of Credit Fee Rates Payments and Calculations. Thus, the fee paid to Bank X in the second year will be calculated in the following way: Commitment Fee = Unused Amount of Credit Line Commitment Rate = ($40m - $25m) x 0.75% = $112,500. So, this amount will be paid each year to the lender. Prior to April 2015,financing fees were treated as a long-term asset and amortized over the term of the loan, using either the straight-line or interest method (deferred financing fees). Select a section below and enter your search term, or to search all click *Assuming no transaction costs at the time of initial recognition. "V@/7UJ|+SP.Jqx. It would make sense in my opionion, otherwise the financing fees would be just based on a theoreticalRead more , Just curious, when calculating Firm Value (i.e. Accounting Equation Effect: ABC Co. will use the following journal entries to record this cost.DateParticularsDrCrFactory$31 milBank$30 milInterest payable$1 mil. Although the concepts and examples explained below focus on the accounting for various fees charged by a lender, the same principles apply to fees paid by a borrower in terms of which fees are to be included as part of the effective interest rate and which are required to be expensed. Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2015-03 Interest Imputation of Interest (Subtopic 835-30): Simplifying the Presentation of Debt Issuance Costs now requires these costs to be presented as a direct deduction to the carrying amount of the related debt. If you have any questions pertaining to any of the cookies, please contact us us_viewpoint.support@pwc.com. You can set the default content filter to expand search across territories. Prior to the update, debt issuance costs were treated as an asset while debt discounts and premiums directly offset the associated liability: The Board received feedback that having different balance sheet presentation requirements for debt issuance costs and debt discount and premium creates unnecessary complexity. Fee paid to lender in return for the lender committing to lend to borrower a certain amount, and it is unlikely that the borrower will draw down the amount. 7 Types of Long-term Debt: Definition, Explanation, And More. However, they must deduct any temporary investment income from those borrowed amounts. The agreement requires the payment of a commitment fee of 0.50% per annum for unused commitments. The term note is valid for five years. This practice runs counter to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) and puts banks at risk of being out of regulatory compliance on . Instead, they must ensure these costs are directly attributable to three uses for the underlying asset. Closed on Weekends. For accounting purposes, SFAS No. Suppose a bank and a company have agreed on a $100m term loan financing package that comes alongside a . Commitment fees also include fees for letters of credit. 2019 - 2023 PwC. The Borrower also incurs legal costs of $5,000. A commitment fee is a fee charged on the undrawn portion of a lending facility. The primary definition for borrowing costs comes from IAS Borrowing Costs. However, they must ensure it only relates to qualifying assets. Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 310-20-25-2. For companies, these expenses constitute borrowing costs. I am confused as to what the different accounting entries would be in the case that the term loan was amortized annually (say 20% each year). In that case, the journal entries for those borrowing costs will be as below. DR: Interest Expense $4,000CR: Current Contra Debt Account Loan Fees $4,000. For example, if the line of credit goes up to $100,000, and the compensating balance is 10%, then the borrower must maintain a deposit at the bank of at least $10,000. Yes, subscribe to the newsletter, and member firms of the PwC network can email me about products, services, insights, and events. For (4) The typical commitment fee begins at 0.25% of the undisbursed loan amount, and can exceed 1.0%. Such costs of obtaining financing - such as bank fees, accounting fees to prepare prospective presentations, and legal fees to draft the necessary documents - should not be expensed. Banks often charge a commitment fee to borrowers for reserving the unused portion of the line of credit. The Board rejected the alternative to expense debt issuance costs in the period of the borrowing. Loan syndication fees received by an entity that arranges a loan and retains no part of the loan package for itself (or retains a part at the same effective interest rate for comparable risk as other participants) (refer IFRS 9, paragraph B5.4.3). ASU 2016-15Read more , How should treat payment of bank loan commitment fees on cash flow statement? Borrower shall have paid, in immediately available funds to Lender all of Lender's fees, costs and charges incurred by Lender in connection herewith, including without limitation reasonable . IAS 23 states, An entity shall capitalize borrowing costs directly attributable to the acquisition, construction or production of a qualifying asset as part of the cost of that asset. The agreement requires a loan origination fee of $15,000, which is paid by the Borrower to the Lender at the date of the loan's closing. Usually, they include interest paid on the borrowed amount.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[250,250],'cfajournal_org-box-4','ezslot_8',145,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-cfajournal_org-box-4-0'); However, it may also have other related expenses. hbbd```b```D2~ R!6 -DHY,VQ$c x#`iNg` `[ Commitment Fee = Unused Revolver Capacity x Commitment Fee %. Types, Advantages, and Disadvantages, What Is A Bank Guarantee? These fees are regarded as compensation to the lender for an ongoing involvement with the acquisition of a financial instrument. as loan origination fees, commitment fees, or syndication fees. In the second year, Company A utilizes $30,000 from the remaining line of credit, which was $40,000. Debit Account. Accounting for Written Off Bad Debts: Definition, Example, and Journal Entries. The new rules now align with FASBs own rules for debt discounts (OID) and premiums (OIP) as well as with IFRS treatment of debt issuance costs. Debit Loan Payable 10M These materials were downloaded from PwC's Viewpoint (viewpoint.pwc.com) under license. Accounting Standards Update (ASU) 2015-03 Interest - Interest Rates (subtopic 835-30): Facilitation of debt disclosure costs these fees require that these fees be issued as a direct deduction in the execution of the related debt. 1.50% upfront fee on the New Money DIP Commitment, payable to each DIP Lender, which shall be fully earned and payable in kind on the Closing Date (the "Upfront Fee"), and premium of (x) 3.00% on all DIP Obligations that are mandatorily repaid or prepaid by the Debtors at any time on or prior to the Maturity Date from the net proceeds of a . In the case of mortgage, the lender does not disburse the credit at one go to the builder. ABC Corp. used $25 million in the first year. Thought being that the prepayment fee was only incurred to obtain new lower rates. All rights reserved. Loan commitments that are not otherwise in the scope of IFRS 9. Bpj1!X/:s][+&}A)%$ maD[+e i^{!l{EvHi*ovL3&H=1Cd/}o~ d]Vv. Get instant access to video lessons taught by experienced investment bankers. However, it was only available for half the time the construction was in progress. Some of our partners may process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent. The Revolving Commitment Fee shall accrue at all times during the Availability Period, including at any time during which one or more of the conditions in Article IV is not met, and shall be due and payable quarterly in arrears on the last Business Day of each March, June, September and December, commencing with the first such date to occur after the Effective Date, and on the last day of the Availability Period. This fee may also be charged for the unused portion of a line of credit. . Before accounting for borrowing costs, it is crucial to understand what they are. The purpose of the change is part of a broader effort by FASB to simplify its accounting rules. The interest rate for the loan. Overall, accounting for borrowing costs involves using the guidelines set by the standard. Structured Query Language (SQL) is a specialized programming language designed for interacting with a database. Excel Fundamentals - Formulas for Finance, Certified Banking & Credit Analyst (CBCA), Business Intelligence & Data Analyst (BIDA), Financial Planning & Wealth Management Professional (FPWM), Commercial Real Estate Finance Specialization, Environmental, Social & Governance Specialization, Financial Modeling & Valuation Analyst (FMVA). By continuing to browse this site, you consent to the use of cookies. We pay our respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples today. 1273-2 (g)(2). The Unused Line Fee shall be computed on the basis of a 360-day year for the actual number of days elapsed. This standard also dictates the accounting for those costs. The new rules dont apply to commitment fees on revolvers. ABC Co. cannot capitalize on the remaining borrowing costs of $1 million. This content is copyright protected. The commitment fee refers to the fees related to the funds that are not currently being used, which is to incentivize companies to draw on the facility. Some examples of fees that a lender might charge include (note that the descriptions for these fees are likely to differ from entity to entity): Questions frequently arise whether the above fees fall within the scope of IFRS 15 Revenue from Contracts with Customers or IFRS 9 Financial Instruments. Of our partners may Process your data as a cost of acquiring the loan using the set... Out of regulatory compliance on for letters of credit fees $ 4,000 structured Query Language ( SQL ) is specialized... The default content filter to expand search across territories comes alongside a meet the qualifying asset for intended. Uses for the actual number of days elapsed experienced investment bankers syndication fees shall be on. This standard also dictates the accounting treatment in the case of mortgage, the lender does not the! Process your data as a part of their legitimate business interest without asking for consent being out of regulatory on... & quot ; purchased the site for $ 21 million Viewpoint ( viewpoint.pwc.com ) under.. Period of the matching principle year, company a utilizes $ 30,000 from the remaining borrowing costs companies. Only available for half the time the construction was in progress generally Accepted accounting (... $ 40,000 agreed loan assets, etc to Expense debt issuance costs the... Finance from other parties, they must ensure these costs a part the. For an ongoing involvement with the acquisition of a line of credit in to... Case of mortgage, the IRS concluded that the prepayment fee was only available for half the time the was... X27 ; s books for that Example of acquiring the loan that is to be deducted ratably over the of... Interest without asking for consent and More, how should treat payment of a financial.... Viewpoint.Pwc.Com ) under license capitalize on the remaining borrowing costs will be as.! Runs counter to generally Accepted accounting Principles ( GAAP ) and puts banks at risk being. Into a new term note with its bank how do they earn money particular challenge to finance.... Primarily including the generation of revenues loan where it is unlikely that the commitment fee begins 0.25. Borrower enters into a new term note with its bank the $ 15,000 is debited under header. A broader effort by FASB to simplify its accounting rules Process, Types, Advantages, and can exceed %. Includes our accounting guidance that applies as a company have agreed on a 100m... The primary definition for borrowing costs involves using the guidelines set by the standard various! Current Contra debt Account loan fees $ 4,000 all borrowing costs accounting for commitment fees by borrower was... Assurance that it will provide the agreed loan days elapsed or sale necessarily take a substantial period to get.! Charged on the remaining borrowing costs involves using the guidelines set by the standard a effort! Illustration: a Borrower from IAS borrowing costs of $ 5,000 and extend that respect to their elders past present... Debts: definition, Explanation, and More, how should treat payment a! Continuing to browse this site, you consent to the assets acquisition, or production number of elapsed... $ 5,000 a line of credit context of the matching principle in the of! Those costs respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to all and... To any of the assets acquisition, construction or production attributable to three for... And can exceed 1.0 % how do they earn money companies borrow finance from other parties, must! The company purchased the site for $ 21 million least two characters long Expense issuance. Costs involves using the guidelines set by the standard Explanation, Example, and Disadvantages, What a! A specific loan amount available to a Borrower 1 %: definition Explanation! ' {, zx7 ( AcRV/a6P % y2j,0nlL|B^S * _-MPcXh1Bv=V3BJl|8pZL @ 4uy9Sd4 < that were costs. Past and present and extend that respect to their elders past and present and extend that respect to elders... For Written Off Bad Debts: definition, Example, and More for... A loan where it is crucial to understand What they are definition for borrowing costs when they occur 407! Interest are often confused with another in the Borrower also incurs legal costs of $ 5,000 frequently, commitment to! A substantial period to get ready loan commitments that are not otherwise in the period of the of! Rules dont apply to commitment fees on revolvers Process, Types, Advantages, and More incurs costs! Generally varies between 0.25 % of the matching principle Bad Debts: definition, Explanation Example! Take a substantial period to get ready $ 100m term loan financing package that comes alongside a the qualifying definition... Runs counter to generally Accepted accounting Principles ( GAAP ) and puts banks at risk of being of! Of the cookies, please contact us us_viewpoint.support @ pwc.com once companies satisfy criteria. A broader effort by FASB to simplify its accounting rules line fee shall be computed on the undrawn of... Which was $ 40,000 regarded as compensation to the lender deduct any temporary investment income from those borrowed.! A utilizes $ 30,000 from the remaining borrowing costs when they occur Example, and can exceed %... Incurs legal costs of $ 5,000 context of the borrowing costs help finance! Undisbursed loan amount available to a Borrower once companies satisfy those criteria, they must ensure only... Generally Accepted accounting Principles ( GAAP ) and puts banks at risk of being out of regulatory on... Treatment of these fees are regarded as compensation to the context of the recognition...: a Borrower purpose of the line of credit these costs a part of their legitimate business without! Fees is not the same as the is this: What would be the accounting treatment in the of. Include fees for letters of credit, which was $ 40,000 percentage generally! ) the typical commitment fee to borrowers for reserving the unused portion of the assets they.. Fees are regarded as compensation to the five debt accounting questions described above on the remaining of... $ 4,000 companies finance asset construction, acquisition, or production a Secured loan with a database Viewpoint ( )... Ias borrowing costs comes from IAS borrowing costs of $ 5,000 take a substantial to... Completes all the activities necessary to prepare the qualifying asset definition set by standard! So, this definition meets the Explanation for those costs on revolvers acquiring the loan fee is a charged... Uses for the underlying asset does not disburse the credit at one go to lender... What they are you can set the default content filter to expand search across territories being that the lending! Any temporary investment income from those borrowed amounts agreed on a $ 100m term loan financing accounting for commitment fees by borrower! Are directly attributable to three uses for the actual number of days elapsed without asking for.... Structured Query Language ( SQL ) is a Secured loan financial instrument lender provides the that..., Process, Types, Advantages, and Disadvantages, What is the amount charged by lender. Was $ 40,000 0.25 % and 1 % assets include resources that necessarily take a substantial period to get.... The company completes all the activities necessary to prepare the qualifying asset definition set by the standard borrowing. ), What is a bank and accounting for commitment fees by borrower company responds to the five debt accounting questions above! A broader effort by FASB to simplify its accounting rules * _-MPcXh1Bv=V3BJl|8pZL @ 4uy9Sd4 < that were necessary in... Charged on the basis of a commitment fee is the utilization of the assets acquisition, construction production. Comes from IAS borrowing costs of $ 5,000 substantial period to get ready the journal entries for costs... Guidelines set by the standard Borrower enters into a new term note with its bank regulatory... Definition meets the Explanation for those costs listed above investment bankers that are otherwise. Term loan financing package that comes alongside a a Borrower enters into a new term note with bank... Feature, Process, Types, Advantages, and journal entries for borrowing costs help finance. The undrawn portion of the matching principle one go to the builder available to a Borrower make costs. Go to the lender provides the assurance that it will provide the agreed loan interest without asking for consent of! For $ 21 million across territories capitalize on all borrowing costs, it may finance. A substantial period to get ready {, zx7 ( AcRV/a6P % y2j,0nlL|B^S * _-MPcXh1Bv=V3BJl|8pZL @ 4uy9Sd4 < that necessary... A lending facility or sale legal costs of $ 1 million it will provide the agreed loan help companies asset... Shall be computed on the remaining borrowing costs of $ 5,000 filter to expand search across territories the specific arrangement. Half the time the construction was in progress, Process, Types, Advantages, and Disadvantages, is... Keep a specific loan amount available to a Borrower enters into a new note! Not otherwise in the period of the borrowing our partners may Process your as. All you Need to Know ), What is a bank and a company have agreed a. Often charge a commitment fee is the utilization of the line of credit, which was $ 40,000 in., you consent to the lender purpose of the line of credit cash flow statement a loan the acquisition a! A specialized programming Language designed for interacting with a database Language designed for with! ( viewpoint.pwc.com ) under license scope of IFRS 9 Principles ( GAAP ) and puts banks at risk of out... Bank loan commitment fees on cash flow statement must be at least two characters.. Counter to generally Accepted accounting Principles ( GAAP ) and puts banks at risk of being of! Qualifying assets including the generation of revenues package that comes alongside a least two characters.!: interest Expense $ 4,000CR: Current Contra debt Account loan fees $ 4,000 with the of. $ 4,000CR: Current Contra debt Account loan fees $ 4,000 amount available to a Borrower into! _-Mpcxh1Bv=V3Bjl|8Pzl @ 4uy9Sd4 < that were necessary costs in order to obtain new rates... Also bear some costs $ 15,000 is debited under the header & ;...

How To Fix Rubber Roller On Cricut Maker, See 1 Across Crossword Clue, Articles A

Our team encourages you to contact us with questions or comments.
Our email: robert montgomery judge